Adapting the fan duct

Lots of fanducts to choose from these days :smile:

Here’s my latest addition. It might not be the prettiest but I think the performance should be good. I have no 5015 atm so I haven’t tested it yet…


4 Likes

Boy, this is turning into a contest…
Looks awesome… I do not come at all with the printing behind…

Yes, it does indeed :rofl: Let’s see if someone will do a scientific comparison of all these variants someday.

Here is my 5015 Motorcover and Airduct for the J1 - it’s my first Version and under develeopment :wink:

2 Likes

Haven’t tried it yet but just printed and installed rwide’s dual fan design. Just have to splice and plug in fans. It looks like it will cool really well. The only downside is the fan intake not being symmetrical. I might add a little fan grill to partial mask it. For now I’m just going to black out the sticker.

2 Likes

Looks nice. I hope it performs well! :smiley:
Let me know if you need any step files!

1 Like

I mounted Rwides fan ducts and printed an overhang test to compare the stock fan duct to his design black Rwides /Wihte stock.

1 Like

Interesting! I cant reallly tell from the images but black seems a little better? Is that a layershift that I see on the white part?

What is your conclusion? :face_with_monocle: :smile:

There was no layershift only to little cooling.

I did another test:
Black Rwide fan / White Stock
Rwide 50% fan speed
Stock 100% fan speed

Definitely better overhangs on black.

2 Likes

Oh I see. Very nice! :smiley: :+1:
Thanks for posting!

Have you tested it meanwhile? I’m on the fence between this and the one from @Mechanikus

My J1 is collecting dust atm. Waiting for a new x-rail from Snapmaker, so I still haven’t tested the new 2-way duct. @Execodor’s image comparison with the stock cooling setup looks promising though…
In theory, my 2-way design does have the potential to have an advantage over @Mechanikus design on certain geometries, but it is still very possible that mechanikus design in the end turns out to be better. I suppose it depends on how well designed my 2-way version is…

Thanks, but I cannot take full credit for the fan nozzle - I only fine-tuned and optimised the design from ā€œMauro3D_MIā€.

My stomach feeling would be that the last design of Rwide might be better in some cases since it cools from two sides. A negative side is the longer distance to the nozzle. I guess only a lot of tests would tell which nozzle is better for which design :wink:
But I will stick with my own ones since I want to be able to easily switch hotends and as far as I can see from the pictures that might be an obstacle with all the other designs.

That’s a valid point. I too have additional hotends that I’d like to keep switchable easily.

If that is your priority then the mechanikus version might be the safer choice… Perhaps @Execodor or @Plasticrap3d can answer if a duct is in the way when pulling out the hotend?

Which version of Rwide’s design are you using?

It’s this one: Covers and fanducts for Snapmaker J1 by Rwide - Thingiverse

Have you modified the heatbreak on all of your additional hot ends?
Just realized, that you have 2 distinct fan mods one for stock and a shortened one for the heatbreak mod. I assume if I start to change the heatbreak on one pair, I have to do it on all additional hotend pairs as well. Expensive journey. :thinking: