Yeah, that’s the likely calculus of it. Understandable enough, but really itching for an open standard. It does feel like magic when you put a known spool on and it just knows what it is.
You can find some information in this video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9oqZxi5NVQ with Blayne Sapelli (at about 45:00) in the next layer Podcast. Blayne seems interested in an open-source RFID standard and the TigerTag techno. I don’t know, but it doesn’t seem ready yet (or he doesn’t want to give an annoncement too early). It’s interesting, but I guess there’s probably a financial agreement between Snapmaker and Polymaker and that’s blocking this development of an RFID universal standard now I guess. Maybe my English isn’t good enough to understand Blayne’s thoughts !
I think Blayne is walking a tight rope of what he can say about R&D and what he thinks they should do when talking publicly. I got the impression that he was for the open source RFID tags and was trying to convenience SM to go that direction.
I’ve just seen something about a nightly build or firmware beta release that allows for generic RFID tags to be used and be read by the U1 side loaded filament readers.
Anyone able to comment on the RFID tag format, is it compatible with OpenPrintTag?
OpenPrintTag hardware specs are not released. So it is not possible to tell with certainty what is or is not compatible with it.
By the looks of it, openPrinTag is using NFC tech. Where U1 has RFID (mifare 1k tags) they are not compatible. Unless you swap upgrade the reader on U1, install drivers to the Linux head, and make it all work with klipper.
The current U1 reader does not support OpenPrintTag. OPT uses SLIX2 with ISO 15693 framing, which is not supported by the FM17550 reader used in U1. U1 only supports ISO 14443 A/B.
My firmware adds a support low-cost NTAG21x tags, which can be programmed with any Android or iOS phone. It implements RFID Tags | OpenSpool format.
The MIFARE Classic 1K used by Snapmaker spools relies on asymmetric cryptography to validate the signature of written tags.
Thank you for clarifying @paxx12, and it was your work I saw on a YT channel that dropped in my feed. I haven’t visited your Github yet, so asked the question here. Appreciate the link too.